Brighton Summary - October 2024

How Smart Bidding Really Works

Key Takeaways

  1. The Power of Smart Bidding:

    • Dramatic improvements possible: In one case, 97% decrease in cost per conversion, 3,282% increase in conversion rate, and 15,100% increase in conversions in 32 days.
  2. Core Principles of Smart Bidding Success:

    • Feed the beast: Provide ample, quality data to the algorithm.
    • Exclude permanently: Use data exclusions wisely and don't remove them.
    • Model extensively: Understand and work with the underlying models.
  3. Bayes' Theorem:

    • Smart Bidding uses Bayesian probability, continuously updating its beliefs based on new data.
  4. Pinning Ads:

    • Pin ads only when necessary, as it can limit the algorithm's learning and optimization.
  5. ARIMA Models:

    • Google uses ARIMA (Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average) models for forecasting.
  6. Common Pitfalls:

    • Google Ads can't see "All Conversions" - ensure it has visibility into the right data.
    • Messing with historical data can confuse the algorithm.
    • Not allowing Google enough time to learn can lead to suboptimal performance.
  7. Modeling the Model:

    • Understanding and modeling Google's approach can lead to better strategy and results.

Action Items

  1. Review Data Feeding:

    • Ensure you're providing comprehensive, quality data to the Smart Bidding algorithm.
    • Check that all relevant conversion actions are visible to Google Ads.
  2. Audit Data Exclusions:

    • Review your current data exclusions.
    • Avoid removing existing exclusions as it can disrupt the algorithm's learning.
  3. Experiment with Unpinned Ads:

    • Test campaigns with unpinned ads to allow for more algorithmic learning.
  4. Explore ARIMA Models:

    • Search for "ARIMA_PLUS" in Google Ads to understand how Google is forecasting for your campaigns.
  5. Allow Learning Time:

    • Be patient and give Google's algorithm time to learn and optimize before making major changes.
  6. Avoid Historical Data Manipulation:

    • Refrain from altering past data, as it can confuse the Smart Bidding algorithm.
  7. Model Your Approach:

    • Develop your own models to understand and predict Smart Bidding behavior.
    • Use this understanding to inform your bidding strategies and optimizations.
  8. Continuous Learning:

    • Stay updated on Smart Bidding developments and best practices.
    • Consider downloading the presenter's Data Exclusions slides for more in-depth information.

Remember: Smart Bidding is powerful but requires a deep understanding of its underlying principles and careful management of data inputs. Success comes from working with the algorithm, not against it.

For more information:

  • LinkedIn: Nathan Ifill
  • Twitter: @nathanifill
  • Presentation Deck: speakerdeck.com/nathanifill